|
iWorld cup iyeza. Sonwabile, kodwa ziphi iitoilets? The World cup is coming. We are happy, but where are the toilets?
It’s the 31st of December 2010, and looking back, we would like to remember how Bafana made it to the finals, surprising everyone by winning the world cup. By the looks of it, we will have a lot more to remember 2010 by, other than the world cup. Instead, we will remember that moment of madness when City of Cape Town officials, under heavy police protection and armed with hacksaws, hammers and elbow grease, removed the now uncovered toilets, and the only place where an already impoverished community could answer Mother Nature’s call. If this was a game of chess, it was the exact move the ANC-youth league wanted to illicit from the DA-lead municipality. A more appropriate response from the City of Cape Town would have been to give the community the many unused concrete enclosures and left the youth-league to make the next move.
So what was the thinking behind this attitude of, ‘we’ll show them who runs the city’ approach to dealing with this situation? Was there actual thinking happening at all? An eye for eye leaves everyone blind, so the saying goes. A little creativity and ingenuity goes a long way in dealing with challenges – using force and being vindictive is not sustainable.
So, why this scant disregard for the people who already have so little? Is it because the community is perceived to be pro-ANC supporters and winning their hearts and minds is not a priority? Is it because this community is out of sight of the hordes of visitors from across the world, and therefore they don’t matter? Is it because they are perceived to be outsiders from the former ‘Bantustans’ of Venda, Ciskei.? Or is it because they just don’t matter because they are poor, vulnerable, and dare I say, they are ‘black’ and let’s face it, ‘these’ people from the rural areas are used to relieving themselves in the bush and damn, aren’t they lucky to have gotten toilets to begin with? A horrible thing to say and even to consider, but have we not become complacent as a nation in the face of rampant crime, new born babies dying because of sheer neglect, and so forth? And of course why can’t the naughty ANC-youth league buggers behave just once when the visitors arrive. They can continue with their shenanigans after the world cup – for now, let’s show the world we are united in misery, poverty and discomfort.
|
Comments
in my view I think Dan Plato the mayor of Cape Town he personalized this issue of toilets and as a results of that he could not control his anger and become reactional and took the worst decision by instructing city officials to remove the toilets. in his response he wasted the tax payers money. Ofcourse the ANC Youth league was very smart by capitalising on the issue of toilets which draw international attention. I guess it was their strategy to attach themselves on the ground with a view to mobilise support for next upcoming local elections and ofcourse in their action the youth league was not honest because they wanted to use the poor for political gain and that is why they will not sustain the issue of toilets. Mzonke Poni the Chairperson of Abahlali baseMjondolo Western Cape
Underlying all this is a desperate need for the state to recognise the value a rights based approach to development and economic growth in achieving equity, which is more than simply quasi-constitutional rights, but a meaningfully space to participate in long term development of the city. Are we seeing important democractic spaces closing in our pursuit of the world class city? If so, what does this mean for our democracy and in particular the urban poor who are increasingly silenced in the pursuit of the right to the city?
As we look back to this most wonderful time of the FiFa 2010 World Cup on our continent, in our country with Cape Town as one of the host city’s we will be proud indeed of our achievements but the Khayelitsha toilets saga will continue to be a blight in our landscape as we bask in that glory.
RSS feed for comments to this post